Is Defunding Police a Knee Jerk Response?

“Curt began walking furiously along the centre line.” (photo: unsplash.com)


Almost without exception, the Young Offenders we worked with at Camp Colonial in Hedley came from fractured, dysfunctional homes. Untrusting, minimally acquainted with the truth, devious, suspicious of almost everyone, they had gravitated to criminal activity. In spite of the negatives that had crept into their lives, most were eminently likeable. Curt, a skinny16 year old youth from Kamloops was all the above, but he really wasn’t easy to like. An aura of deep disgruntlement pervaded the space around him. His moods were erratic and people felt uneasy in his presence. Possibly he suffered from an undiagnosed mental illness. Because he had come with a reputation for being unpredictable and at times violent, an experienced staff was assigned to work with him exclusively.

In the midst of the current angry protests against police violence and calls for defunding, I was reminded of an incident involving Curt. His mother had arrived by Greyhound to visit him on a warm June day. Larry, his worker noted a good deal of agitated whispering and an underlying friction simmering between them. It was evident she too was not mentally and emotionally stable. At the end of the day, as she was about to board the bus to leave, she French kissed Curt. He seemed to accept this as part of their usual routine.

We had learned to expect that a visit from a parent could easily cause a kid to become distraught at being left behind. That evening I was Duty Officer and at about 8 pm I received an urgent call from Larry on my two way radio. “Curt has become totally unhinged,” Larry said. “He’s in the program office and has locked the door. There are crashing sounds. He’s trashing the place.”

I arrived at the site within minutes and attempted to make voice contact with Curt. He was shouting obscenities at the world and smashing furniture. Apparently he had withdrawn into some dark inner space that shut out my attempts to communicate. Suddenly he burst from the office, leaving the door hanging from its top hinge. In his haste he nearly knocked me down. Running frantically, he made his way to the highway skirting our community. Stopping in the middle of the highway, he began walking furiously along the white centre line, quite oblivious of the traffic speeding by him.

On my 2 way handset I instructed Larry to request help from the RCMP. I called on a worker to follow him at a distance and another to be ahead, signaling drivers to slow down. Cautiously I approached Curt and began walking beside him, speaking quietly. He was in his own world and seemed unaware of my presence. Fortunately drivers understood something unusual and potentially life threatening was at play. They didn’t honk horns or shout complaints. I thought of pushing Curt physically off the highway but feared in his irrational state he might pull us both into the path of a vehicle. I was waiting for his energy to dissipate and for the police to arrive.

After several miles, Curt left the highway and entered a small cafe that was popular with truckers. At the same time a single Mountie in a police cruiser arrived. I hurriedly explained the situation and he entered the cafe. I felt my presence might be a distraction so I waited outside with several workers. After a few minutes the Mountie, a well built man of about 35, emerged and we watched as he unloaded his side arm. “I’m not taking any chances there,” he said, as much to himself as to us. His tone suggested an understanding of Curt’s mental state.

He left the cafe door open and we heard Curt’s shrill voice and the officer’s calm responses. After about an hour Curt’s anger had run its course. When they emerged, he was handcuffed and meekly entered the back door of the cruiser. “We’ll look after Curt overnight,” the Mountie said. “You can pick him up in the morning.” I thanked the big man for his patience. By remaining calm he had given us another opportunity to win Curt’s trust and discover it was possible to like him.

I’m aware that our society has become vastly more complex over the years. Even so, this Mountie’s patience and willingness to dialogue suggests that with a constructive emphasis in training, more marginalized people might respect, not fear the police. Defunding seems an ineffective, knee jerk response.

Spencer Coyne, Community Minded Mayor

Spencer Coyne with a possible future mayor on a tour of Princeton Town Hall. (Photo by Andrea DeMeer)

At the end of a conversation with Spencer Coyne recently, I asked if he has thoughts of making the switch to provincial politics when Linda Larson retires after this term. He responded without hesitation. “I was here when the mine closed in 1996,” he said. “I watched people leave, including some of my own family, because jobs dried up. It broke my heart. Seeing so many good people leave made me feel lonely. We have a strong community now and my goal is to see it thrive. Local government is where we can be most effective in strengthening Princeton and the entire Similkameen valley. My job as mayor isn’t nearly done.”

Spencer’s family roots go down a long way in Princeton. “I was born here, a descendant of Nora,” he said, referring to the iconic indigenous woman who operated a pack train hauling supplies from Hope to Greenwood. She was the first wife of John Fall Allison, an early settler. Spencer’s great grandfather bought a farm in the Princeton area, wanting to provide for his future family. Spencer grew up in the midst of uncles, aunts and cousins. He and his family live on the farm and his parents operate a market garden there. “I’m very much a product of my family and community.”

As a kid, school wasn’t easy for Spencer. “I was dyslexic,” he said. “Reading was extremely difficult, and I dreaded spelling tests. In time I learned to work around this though and now I’m an avid reader.”

His first foray into the uncertain world of politics came in grade 5 when he managed the campaign of a friend running to be class president. “We lost,” he said with a chuckle.

Apparently the experience whetted his appetite. “I enrolled at the University College of the Okanagan, intending to become a teacher.” He was soon diverted from this goal. “I got elected to the student government as VP of Student Services. We provided all services to students and I was responsible for a budget in the millions. We had extensive negotiations with the Administration concerning food services.”

This political experience was a preparation for the future, but he had a restless mind. “I challenged myself and my profs,” he said. “I wanted to understand what I was being taught. Also, I wanted to know if my thinking was sound. I was learning to think critically, but after three years I wondered what my history major was getting me. I decided I needed to return to Princeton and run for Council.”

At age 24 he ran for a seat on council and won. “We laid a lot of groundwork for the future. We established important relationships, especially with the RDOS and the local band.” He had plenty of energy and ideas, but in a run for re-election, he was defeated. “I don’t think the time was right for me. I wanted change, but Princeton wasn’t ready.”

With the approach of the most recent election, he asked his partner and 2 children (now 7 and 10) how they felt about him running for mayor. They approved and he entered the fray with enthusiasm and determination. Winning the right to sit in the mayor’s chair was the easy part. “We’re going to have more people coming to our community,” he said. “Providing affordable housing is a challenge, a balancing act. We’re spending some money on beautification projects. I’d like Princeton to become a destination, not just a place to pull off the highway for gas and a coffee. We don’t want to limit ourselves by thinking ‘this or that.’ We need to think ‘this and that.’ We’re working to bring in new industry and other opportunities that will provide employment.”

I noticed that Spencer laughs easily. “I focus on the positives,” he said. “I feel joy when city staff are happy, and when citizens are happy.” There are challenges along with the positives. “Your life becomes not your own,” he observed. “There’s lots of scrutiny. Giving time to the public instead of my family is the hardest part.”

He focuses on what he and the council are seeking to accomplish. “We have a strong community,” he emphasized, “and we’re getting stronger. We want a community where families feel welcome and safe. No, I have no inclination to jump into provincial politics. Here there is no Party Whip to tell us what we can or cannot do.”

I Bargained With Life…

My curiosity has at times prodded me to lean on a door standing ajar. (Dreamstime photo)

On a Saturday afternoon many years ago, I attended the memorial service for a friend’s spouse. After the formal service there was a coffee time and I was sitting beside a man I didn’t know. I guessed he was about 65. His tanned visage and rugged physique suggested he had spent many years in the outdoors. Turning to me he asked, “What line of work are you in?” I sensed he wanted to know what sort of person I was. Possibly my long black hair and beard intrigued him. Funerals often prod us to dig a little deeper.

“I started as a heavy equipment operator and truck driver,” I replied. “It really wasn’t something I wanted to do my entire working life. I spent 4 years at SFU and earned a degree in sociology and political science. I got a job in community corrections and my work now takes me into prisons like the B.C. Penitentiary, Oakalla, Matsqui Institution and others. We deal with inmates and parolees who have committed serious crimes, including bank robberies, drug trafficking and murder. Our purpose is to provide the supports they need to move beyond a life of crime.”

We talked for about half an hour and when he pushed back his chair to leave he said, “you’ve had an interesting life already. I don’t regret having been a carpenter all my working years, or that my wife and I never moved from this community. I suppose though we could have ventured more.” There was a hint of chagrin in his voice.

I was reminded of this encounter recently while reading Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert. She believes we are all walking repositories of buried treasure. “The hunt to uncover this treasure,” she says, “that’s creative living. The courage to go on that hunt in the first place, that’s what separates a mundane existence from a more enchanted one.”

Looking back now, I have to admit I never really had the courage to embark on that hunt. I was shy and lacked confidence in social situations. Fortunately, I did get help from several sources. Linda and I had been married about two years when I woke one morning, startled by a thought that seemed to have been placed on a shelf directly in front of my face, waiting for me. The thought was “stop living tentatively.” It unsettled me and I wondered where it had come from. Although I had little interest in religion then, I seriously wondered if an angel might have swooped down from on high and deposited it there. I pondered the meaning of this “message,” but didn’t immediately tell Linda.

A second source of help came from the oft quoted poem by Jessie B. Rittenhouse. She wrote “I bargained with life for a penny, and Life would pay no more. However I begged at eventime when I counted my scanty store. For Life is just an employer, he gives you what you ask. But once you have set the wages,why, you must bear the task. I worked for a menial’s hire, only to learn, dismayed, that any wage I had asked of Life, Life would have willingly paid.”

After much discussion, Linda and I agreed we didn’t want to arrive at the end of our days and conclude we had lived tentatively, that we had “bargained with life for a penny.” I left my job operating heavy equipment and Linda resigned from a very secure position at the Royal Bank. We loaded our van and drove to 100 Mile House, without a plan or significant means. We bought a lot on Sheridan Lake, lived there in a tent for about 3 months, then decided I should apply to attend SFU.

Looking back over the years now, I don’t feel I ever became really adept at opening doors of opportunity. However, my curiosity has at times prodded me to lean against a door standing ajar. There have been a few I should not have entered, but I’ve come to somewhat understand Elizabeth Gilbert’s contention that “a creative life is an amplified life, a more interesting life,” even if sometimes we stumble.

$3 Million and a Mercedes

Listening to Donald Patterson’s offer of $3 million
and a Mercedes.

Just before lunch last Tuesday I received a phone call that instantly captured my attention. “Hello,” a pleasant voice said. “My name is Donald Patterson. I’m with Publishers Clearing House. The purpose of my call is to inform you that because you shop at Walmart and Save on Foods, and pay off your credit card monthly, you’ve been selected for one of 4 prizes we give out annually. The prize consists of three million dollars and a brand new Mercedes.”

I was reminded of the saying, “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” Even so, I couldn’t cavalierly blow him off. I’ve long believed it’s important to consider opportunities. Also, there are exceptions to some rules. Maybe this was such a case. Donald’s cheery personality did invite my curiosity.

Skeptical, but also wanting it to be true, I asked, “What do I need to do to receive the money?”
He had anticipated the question. “Not a thing,” he said breezily. “I have a certified cheque on my desk, made out to you. Our office is in Vancouver.” He gave me the address, then said,” I can bring the cheque to you today. Does that suit you, or is another day better?”

I knew scammers sometimes use the name of a reputable, well known company or government agency to establish credibility. Still, a little voice somewhere in the recesses of my brain whispered, “Don’t judge too quickly. What if this is one of those exceptions to the rule? Surely there can be no harm in agreeing to have him come out with a cheque for three million. If the cheque really is certified, you’ll be rich. Let’s see where this goes.”

I didn’t want to be lulled into making a bad decision, but what was the harm in letting him come? At the moment, it didn’t occur to me these thoughts were almost certainly coming from sheer greed, not sound reasoning.

“So, you’re willing to bring me a cheque for three million and I’ll also get a Mercedes?” I asked, then added, “and I don’t have to do anything?”

“That’s correct,” he replied. “Just give me your e-mail address and I’ll send you a confirmation.

Linda had been listening intently to my side of this conversation. She’s more dubious about this type of offer and would have terminated the call immediately. Concerned I’d be duped, she opened her lap top and began sleuthing on the internet.

“All you want is my email address?” I asked. “Yes, yes,” he assured me. “All you need to do is go to the Bank of Montreal and deposit $500 to register your prize. Place the money into the account of Revenue of Canada.” Another recognizable name, but I noted he didn’t have it quite right. Still, if he brought a certified cheque, how could I possibly lose?

We had talked for about ten minutes, but Donald still seemed ok with my dilly dallying. He was like a veteran hunter patiently stalking a deer. “What colour do you want the Mercedes to be?” he asked. “Sky blue,” I said. He chuckled, likely believing I was warming to his magnanimous offer. By now I had decided though this was indeed a scam. I simply wanted to know what further gimmicks he would employ.

Linda now stepped away from her computer and stood very close to me waving her arms in consternation, much like a traffic cop wanting to stop a reckless driver. She feared I would unknowingly provide Donald with personal information he could use for identity theft or some other nefarious purpose. Not wanting to upset her, I said to my new pal, “Donald, my wife is even more skeptical than me. I’ll have to discontinue this conversation.” I’m sure he had been at this juncture many times. “I’m sorry you don’t want the 3 million and the Mercedes, Mr. Martens,” he said. “Good bye.”

Successful scammers understand they’ll lose the majority of these verbal duels. They also know that greed tends to cloud our decision making and by patiently persevering day after day, they will find unsuspecting, vulnerable individuals hoping for the big win. Donald Patterson, by the way, wasn’t in Vancouver as he wanted me to believe. Linda’s sleuthing uncovered the fact he was calling from Jamaica. Apparently that age old rule still holds. “If it’s too good to be true, it is.”